[arm-allstar] Connecting to node 29332

[Gerry Filby]

Well this is weird ...

All 4 of my nodes (48035, 48063, 48866, 49111) answer dns-query and 
check_reg.sh correctly (see below) - so I don't think it's configuration 
on my end.

ALL four nodes successfully ping 69.178.108.173, so it's not likely 
network routing, maybe.

However, 48063 and 48035 can connect to 29332 just fine - but 49111 and 
48866 CAN NOT connect to 29332.

Is there a CLI connect command I can run that will be give me more 
information on why the connection is being refused or failing ?

g

(48035)
[root at node48035 818ctl]# dns-query 29332
+OK|radio at 69.178.108.173:4569/29332,69.178.108.173
[root at node48035 818ctl]# check_reg.sh

Node - 48035 at IP address- 173.228.113.7, Port- 4569 is "Registered" at 
Server
IP- 44.98.254.145 (145.PTR.allstarlink.org. 
register-tpa.allstarlink.org.), Port- 4569

  DNS lookup returns - +OK|radio at 173.228.113.7:4569/48035,173.228.113.7

(48063)
[root at node48063 tmp]# dns-query 29332
+OK|radio at 69.178.108.173:4569/29332,69.178.108.173
[root at node48063 tmp]# check_reg.sh

Node - 48063 at IP address- 198.27.190.130, Port- 4569 is Registered at 
Server
IP- 44.98.254.145 (145.PTR.allstarlink.org. 
register-tpa.allstarlink.org.), Port- 4569

  DNS lookup returns - +OK|radio at 198.27.190.130:4569/48063,198.27.190.130

(48866)
[root at node48866 asterisk]# dns-query 29332
+OK|radio at 69.178.108.173:4569/29332,69.178.108.173
[root at node48866 asterisk]# check_reg.sh

Node - 48866 at IP address- 173.228.113.7, Port- 4567 is "Registered" at 
Server
IP- 44.98.254.145 (145.PTR.allstarlink.org. 
register-tpa.allstarlink.org.), Port- 4569

  DNS lookup returns - +OK|radio at 173.228.113.7:4579/48866,173.228.113.7

(49111)
[root at node49111 tmp]# dns-query 29332
+OK|radio at 69.178.108.173:4569/29332,69.178.108.173
[root at node49111 tmp]# check_reg.sh

Node - 49111 at IP address- 198.27.190.130, Port- 4559 is "Registered" 
at Server
IP- 44.98.254.145 (145.PTR.allstarlink.org. 
register-tpa.allstarlink.org.), Port- 4569

  DNS lookup returns - +OK|radio at 198.27.190.130:4559/49111,198.27.190.130


David McGough wrote on 10/10/18 2:11 PM:
> 
> Hi Gerry,
> 
> Yes, the most recent versions of the HamVoIP release do use the DNS lookup
> method. To test the lookups, from a bash prompt (admin menu option #9),
> use this command:
> 
> 
> [root at Allstar-kb4fxc ~]# dns-query 29332
> +OK|radio at 69.178.108.173:4569/29332,69.178.108.173
> 
> 
> 
> Or from the Asterisk CLI:
> 
> Allstar-kb4fxc*CLI> rpt lookup 29332
> Node:  2288, Method:   DNS, Actual:   DNS, Data: radio at 69.178.108.173:4569/29332,69.178.108.173
> Node:  2289, Method:   DNS, Actual:   DNS, Data: radio at 69.178.108.173:4569/29332,69.178.108.173
> 
> 
> Also, confirm that you node is properly registered using the check_reg.sh
> command from a bash prompt (admin menu option #9), like:
> 
> [root at kb4fxc-portable asterisk]# check_reg.sh
> 
> Node - 41331 at IP address- 12.17.29.6, Port- 4569 is "Registered" at Server
> IP- 44.98.254.145 (145.PTR.allstarlink.org. register-tpa.allstarlink.org.), Port- 4569
> 
>   DNS lookup returns - +OK|radio at 12.17.29.6:4569/41331,12.17.29.6
> 
> Node - allstar/41331#4569 at IP address- 12.17.29.6, Port- 4569 is "Registered" at Server
> IP- 74.91.126.182 (hvdallas2.hamvoip.org.), Port- 4569
> 
>   DNS lookup returns - +OK|radio at 12.17.29.6:4569/41331,12.17.29.6
> 
> 
> Please try these commands and report back.
> 
> 
> 73, David KB4FXC
> 
> 
> 
> On Wed, 10 Oct 2018, "Gerry Filby via ARM-allstar" wrote:
> 
>> The past several days I have not been able to connect to node 29332
>> (Alaska hub) from any of my nodes (all latest Hamvoip images).
>>
>> I contacted allstarlink.org and Bryan W9CR had me go looking for:
>>
>> /var/lib/asterisk/rpt_extnodes
>>
>> ... which is indeed not there.
>>
>> It just occurred to me that it might be to do with the changes in
>> hamvoip to implement "DNS" ?
>>
>> I apologize I haven't kept up with this thread - can you steer me in the
>> right direction - is this something I fix in my node, or is there a
>> problem with 29332 - Allstarlink says 29332 is registered and shouldn't
>> be a problem.
>>
>> Thx !
>>
>> Gerry
>> W6WNG
>> _______________________________________________
>>
>> ARM-allstar mailing list
>> ARM-allstar at hamvoip.org
>> http://lists.hamvoip.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/arm-allstar
>>
>> Visit the BBB and RPi2/3 web page - http://hamvoip.org
>>
>